Skip to content

How to Review AI-Generated Code Without Losing Your Mind

AI code looks clean but hides real issues. Here's the REVIEW method: a 6-step process specifically designed for reviewing AI-generated PRs efficiently.

8 min read
A hand carefully inspecting a circuit board using a jeweler’s loupe.
On this page

Code review was already hard. Then AI entered the picture and made it three times harder. Not because AI code is worse. Because it's different in ways that break your existing review habits.

I used to spend 20-30 minutes reviewing a typical PR. Now, for AI-heavy PRs, I spend 15 minutes on the code and 30 minutes on what the code doesn't show. That shift took me a while to figure out.

Why Traditional Code Review Fails for AI Code

When a human writes code, the PR tells a story. You can see their thought process in the commit history. You can infer their intent from the changes they made. You know they had context about the existing system because they work in it daily.

A generated diff may omit the reasoning and repository context needed to evaluate it. Read the requirements and existing implementation, then check behaviour and edge cases even when the formatting and names look convincing.

The three review traps I fell into:

  1. The formatting trap. AI code is beautifully formatted. Your eyes glide over it. You approve faster because it looks professional.
  2. The naming trap. AI picks reasonable variable names. You don't question the logic because the names make sense.
  3. The completeness trap. AI generates comprehensive-looking code with error handling, comments, and types. You assume it covers all the cases because it covers a lot of them.

The REVIEW Method for AI Code

The REVIEW methodRead requirementsExamine edge casesVerify patternsInspect securityEvaluate testsWatch complexity
Figure 1. The REVIEW method covers the intended behaviour, failure paths, architecture, security, tests and complexity.

I developed a 6-step method specifically for reviewing AI-generated PRs. It takes about 25 minutes per PR once you get the hang of it.

R - Read the Requirements First

Before looking at the code, read the ticket or requirements doc. Write down the 3 most important things the code must do. Then check if the code does those 3 things. AI code often solves a slightly different problem than what was asked.[1]

E - Examine Edge Cases

AI is consistently weak on edge cases. For every function, ask yourself:

  • What happens with null or undefined input?
  • What happens with an empty array or empty string?
  • What happens with concurrent requests?
  • What happens when the network fails?
typescript
// AI generated this user lookup
async function getUserByEmail(email: string): Promise<User> {
  const user = await prisma.user.findUnique({
    where: { email },
  });
  return user!; // <-- Non-null assertion. What if the user doesn't exist?
}

// What it should be
async function getUserByEmail(email: string): Promise<User | null> {
  const normalizedEmail = email.trim().toLowerCase();
  if (!normalizedEmail || !normalizedEmail.includes("@")) {
    return null;
  }
  return prisma.user.findUnique({
    where: { email: normalizedEmail },
  });
}

V - Verify Against Existing Patterns

Open 2-3 similar files in your codebase. Does the AI code follow the same patterns? Check specifically:

  • Error handling approach
  • Import style and dependency choices
  • Naming conventions
  • File/folder structure

I - Inspect Security Boundaries

AI consistently generates code with security gaps. My checklist:[2]

markdown
- [ ] Authentication check present where needed?
- [ ] Authorization check (not just authn)?
- [ ] Input validated and sanitized?
- [ ] SQL/NoSQL injection possible?
- [ ] Secrets hardcoded anywhere?
- [ ] Rate limiting considered?
- [ ] CORS configured properly?
- [ ] Sensitive data in logs?

E - Evaluate Test Quality

Don't just check that tests exist. Check what they actually test.[3]

typescript
// AI generated test (looks complete, tests nothing useful)
test("processPayment should process payment", async () => {
  const result = await processPayment({
    amount: 100,
    currency: "USD",
    userId: "user-1",
  });
  expect(result).toBeDefined();
  expect(result.status).toBe("success");
});

// What a useful test looks like
test("processPayment should fail for amounts below $0.50", async () => {
  await expect(
    processPayment({ amount: 0.49, currency: "USD", userId: "user-1" })
  ).rejects.toThrow("Amount below minimum");
});

test("processPayment should be idempotent for same idempotencyKey", async () => {
  const key = "idem-123";
  const payment = {
    amount: 100,
    currency: "USD",
    userId: "user-1",
    idempotencyKey: key,
  };
  const first = await processPayment(payment);
  const second = await processPayment(payment);
  expect(first.chargeId).toBeDefined();
  expect(second.chargeId).toBe(first.chargeId);
});

W - Watch for Unnecessary Complexity

AI loves to over-engineer. It'll add factory patterns, dependency injection, and abstract base classes where a simple function would do. If you find yourself thinking "why is this so complicated?", the answer is probably "because the AI's training data included a lot of enterprise Java patterns."

The complexity sniff test: Can you explain what the code does to a teammate in one sentence? If not, it's probably overcomplicated.

Time-Boxing Your Review

Here's my time allocation for a typical AI-generated PR (500-800 lines):

Phase Time Focus
Requirements check 3 min Does it solve the right problem?
Architecture scan 5 min Does it fit the existing codebase?
Edge case review 5 min What's missing?
Security check 3 min Run through security checklist
Test review 5 min Do tests verify behavior or implementation?
Overall assessment 4 min Would I be comfortable debugging this at 2am?

Total: 25 minutes. Compare to 45+ minutes of unstructured reviewing.

The Contrarian Take

Review triageGreenYellowRed
Figure 2. The author proposes triage by change risk, with deeper review for authentication, payments, migrations and external APIs.

Most teams try to make code reviews faster. I think we should make them more selective. Not every AI-generated PR needs a full REVIEW pass.

My triage system:

  • Green (5 min review): UI tweaks, copy changes, config updates. AI does these well.
  • Yellow (15 min review): New features with no external integrations. Standard REVIEW method.
  • Red (25+ min review): Anything touching auth, payments, data migrations, or external APIs. Full REVIEW method plus a pair review with another senior engineer.

The key insight: spend less time on the code AI gets right (formatting, basic CRUD, UI components) and more time on what it gets wrong (security, edge cases, architecture).

What I Got Wrong

I used to leave long review comments explaining why the AI code was wrong. Complete waste of time. The person who prompted the AI often can't fix the underlying issue because they don't understand it either. They just re-prompt and get slightly different wrong code.

Now, when I find a significant issue in AI-generated code, I write a 3-line fix and push it directly to the branch. Then I leave a comment explaining the issue so the team learns from it. This is 5x faster and actually prevents the issue from recurring.

Making It Sustainable

AI code review fatigue is real. If every PR requires deep investigation, your team will burn out or start rubber-stamping. The antidote is automated guardrails that catch the common issues before code review even starts. Invest in custom ESLint rules, pre-commit hooks, and CI checks. Let machines catch machine mistakes. Save human review time for the things only humans can evaluate: "Does this make sense in context?"[4]

Frequently asked questions

Does every generated pull request need the same review depth?

The article proposes triage based on the consequences of the change. Authentication, payments, migrations and external integrations receive deeper scrutiny, while a smaller change can receive a shorter review with suitable checks.

What should a reviewer read before the diff?

Read the ticket or requirements and identify the behaviour the change must deliver. Use that description when checking edge cases and tests so a plausible implementation can be compared with the actual requested outcome.

How can a reviewer assess generated tests?

Check that assertions cover the required behaviour and failure cases. The payment example should demonstrate how an idempotency key is reused, and assertions should verify an outcome that could fail when the implementation is wrong.

Are the REVIEW timings fixed service levels?

The timings are the author’s proposed allocation for a typical review. Adjust them to the change’s scope and risk, and allow more investigation when the diff includes sensitive data, concurrency or unfamiliar integrations.

Sources

  1. [1]What to look for in a code review · Google Engineering Practices
  2. [2]Secure Code Review Cheat Sheet · OWASP
  3. [3]Secure Coding with AI Cheat Sheet · OWASP
  4. [4]Application card: GitHub Copilot inline suggestions · GitHub Docs

Checked against these sources on

Related Articles